Home-Grown Crime Fiction


Some quick reads well within my comfort zone this past week.

Denise Mina: Gods and Beasts

In the run-up to Christmas, an elderly man and his grandson are queuing at the post-office in Glasgow, when a gunman bursts in and empties the cash register. The elderly man appears to be helping the gunman and gets shot dead for his pains. But what possible connection can a solid pillar of society have with a criminal and why would he hand his grandson over to a weird-looking stranger in the queue? This is not the only investigation that Alex Morrow has to solve: dodgy politicians and criminal gangs, her own brother with his shady dealings, and corruption within her own department make her wonder if there is any part of Glasgow society that she can trust.

Mina can certainly write: she conveys character with just a few traits of the pen and speech patterns. While this story doesn’t quite reach the emotional depth of the Garnethill or Paddy Meehan trilogies, it’s a great read, with an undercurrent of despair. The corruption of politicians and ongoing criminality of Glasgow are ever-present, but there are some characters that you feel hopeful about, some that you hope will be able to create a new life for themselves.

withouttraceSimon Booker: Without Trace

Booker is a TV scriptwriter, and there is an urgent pace and compulsive storytelling quality to his book which proves that. This is less noir than Mina’s work, more of a ‘read all night’ thriller.

Single mother and journalist Morgan Vine has campaigned for more than four years for the release of her childhood sweetheart Danny Kilcannon from prison. She does not believe he killed his wife and stepdaughter, and when a key witness recants his statement, Danny is freed. But then Morgan’s own teenage daughter goes missing and she no longer knows what to believe.

I couldn’t stop reading this, as I too started to doubt and suspect everybody and everything, just like Morgan. Cleverly constructed and full of suspense, with plenty of dodgy characters and grudges, it is a twisty rollercoaster of a book. My one gripe would be that some of the characters are perhaps a bit sketchy or clichéd and the ending felt a trifle over-elaborate and long.

bloodwilltellJeanne M. Dams: Blood Will Tell

Not strictly speaking ‘home-grown’, since the author is American, as is her amateur investigator Dorothy Martin, but Dorothy is married to a retired British chief constable and they are visiting Cambridge, so it will pass muster for now. Except that it really is the vision of olde worlde England and traditional college life that Americans want to see, as the recent success of Downton Abbey has proved.

What I did like was that Dorothy and her husband are in their 70s, happily retired but still keeping themselves very active mentally, although they do complain about their knees and joints and bruises. There aren’t many books featuring elderly investigators out there, so this one has to be praised for that fact alone. The storyline, however, was too cosy and twee, too slow and ponderous for my taste. A bloodstain on the floor leads to all sort of speculations, most of them wrong – it just didn’t arouse my curiosity enough.


19 thoughts on “Home-Grown Crime Fiction”

  1. I have a few from Mina on the shelves but haven’t tried her yet. The Booker looks more my thing than the Dams, but I have enough books already I reckon.

    1. I know what you mean about never getting round to reading what you have on your shelves – this particular book has been waiting patiently for me for a year or two now.

  2. So glad you enjoyed the MIna, Marina Sofia. She is so talented, isn’t she? And the premise of the Booker sounds fascinating. Oh, and I agree with you that it’s nice to have sleuths who are not – erm – thirty any more. I think that trend of having older fiction sleuths is a healthy one, and it may be a reflection of the fact that readers want more diverse characters.

    1. I think that’s why we all love Ruth Galloway and Cathy Ace’s Cait Morgan… at least all of us who are no longer in our 20s! Mind you, some of the more thoughtless things that amateur investigators let themselves in for… might suit – erm – younger people more.

  3. At a guess the Dams isn’t for me (the cosiness and the septuagenarianism are fine by me, it’s the Downton Abbeyness that’s a bit of a turnoff), but you make the other two sound most appetizing.

    I read Mina’s other standalone novel — called Deception over here but Sanctum originally — and liked it really quite a lot for the most part, although by the end I felt it was rather contrived and manipulative. I’ll certainly give Gods and Beasts a try once it comes out in this country . . . probably retitled Famous Five Have a Picnic, or something.

    1. I do like the occasional cosy, just for a change of pace, but no, this was not quite what I expected. I’m very sniffy when it comes to capturing the Cambridge atmosphere!

  4. I have a few of Denise Mina’s books on the good old TBR and really should read them – as you know I’m a huge fan of home-grown crime fiction – glad you found Simon Booker’s foray into books as interesting as I did – it was definitely made for compulsive reading!

  5. I’ve had two shots at reading Denise Mina but haven’t yet cracked it. I think perhaps she is a bit too noir for me. Maybe then, this one might be a way in. As for the second book, I am reading another for review at the moment which has a very similar premise. I should read this and maybe do a comparison post.

      1. Oh, the list would go on forever but they include Peter Robinson, Tana French, Jane Casey, Sharon Bolton, Harry Bingham, Elly Griffiths, Eva Dolan, Claire McGowan and Kate Rhodes

Do share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.