For Translation Thursday and for German Lit Month, here is a German book which has the relationship between parents and children at its very heart. Clearly, although I bought this a while ago, it’s a subject which continues to rumble through all of my recent reading.
After 2 volumes of short stories, Anna Katharina Hahn published her first novel Kurzere Tage (Shorter Days) in 2009. It was highly praised and apparently quite a successful debut. In many respects, it maintains the fragmentary, vignette-like character of a collection of short stories, albeit about the same street in Stuttgart, neighbours who all know each other (more or less). The author examines the cracks in the façade of bourgeois families in a leafy neighbourhood.
Judith is one of those Yummy Mummies who smotes everyone else with judgemental observations: she bakes cakes and doesn’t allow her children to watch TV or play with plastic toys. She is a convert to the therapeutic benefits of cleaning (without the help of a vacuum cleaner) and loves her little routines. Of course, she masks her breath after an occasional cigarette with a mint, and she doesn’t let her husband know that she is popping pills in order to function. Leonie is a working mother whose husband seems to be putting in far too many overtime hours, and often loses her patience with her offspring. Marco is a youngster in danger of turning into a criminal, neglected by his mother and her latest boyfriend. The last POV we encounter is Luise, devoted wife to her beloved Wenzel, the oldest inhabitant in that block of flats, who remembers the deprivation but also the youthful romanticism of the post-war years.
In the hands of a gifted writer, these rather stereotypical characters could find heart and come to life. And perhaps Anna Katharina Hahn is a gifted writer, she has won plenty of prizes and there are plenty of satirical observations and social critique bubbling away underneath the calm surface. The interaction between mothers and children (or the lack thereof) is perhaps the most successful aspect of the novel to me. But I nearly gave up halfway through the book because the minutiae of the description of daily life and household objects was really overwhelming. Nothing was happening, there was no interaction between any of the characters in whose POV we were slipping, and we kept moving from Judith to Leonie then back to Judith again, and it didn’t seem to be leading anywhere. What kept me going was sheer bloody-mindedness and refusal to acknowledge I could have wasted 9 euros plus P&P to have the book shipped over from Germany. It did improve in the end – and the young boy and old woman’s scenes were particularly affecting. However, it was a lesson in how NOT to start a novel.
Stuttgart? Close to where I grew up. And just so the code for the ‘ü’ is ALT+0252 for a small letter.
Ah, OK, I usually have all the ‘strange’ signs in one Word document, but it was inaccessible at the time.
‘strange’ signs. I have one of ’em in my last name. At least they are not accents 😉
Really? ü is ALT + 129, ä is ALT + 132 and ö is ALT +148 (and ß is ALT +225!). I just memorise them as I need them a lot 😉
Yeah, I was never keen on trying this, and I think I was right not to give it a go…
Is now the time to confess that I have no idea what you are talking about? I’m trying to press the keys you are talking about and it’s not working. And I can’t remember what it is on the German keyboard if I switch to that. Plus all of that only works if I am at home, while when travelling with only phone and tablet, it all gets lost…
If you keep the ALT key pressed down while typing those numbers, you get the accented letters
Nice “negative” review
Oh dear – sorry this one didn’t live up to expectations
I thought I might be adding this one to my list to begin with but not now. I liked the sound of the structure but it sounds like a whole lot of nothing.
There were some moving moments, but too few and far away. Shame – it sounded on paper like just the kind of book of close observation and subtlety which would appeal to me.
Not one for me! Oh hear my purse & TBR pile sigh a relief 😉
Sorry to hear that this didn’t do it for you, Marina Sofia. You’re right that too much detail can take away from a plot and keep it from moving along. The concept is interesting – all of these disparate people in the same block – but if it’s not well-executed…
And it was starting to sound good…….
It wasn’t too bad in the end, although perhaps too much was squeezed into the second half, compared with the wasteland of the first half. A deliberate choice perhaps?
Ah, too bad this one didn’t work for you. I really liked it! If I remember correctly, then it was exactly that minutiae that annoyed you that I enjoyed best.
Sorry about that – we can’t all like the same things! Have you written a review of it? Will have to look it up. I think it could have worked in a shorter format, but I got the point about the cataloguing of domestic appliances and moves early on and didn’t need to be constantly reminded of it.
Ah, yes, looking at your review, it was you who made me get this one! Both you and Caroline said how much you liked it, so I ordered it.
Now I am extra sorry that you didn’t like it! There’s nothing like looking forward to a book and then feeling like you wasted your money…
Yes, I did like it. More than that, I absolutely loved it. I still think it’s one of the best German novels of the last decade.
Sorry I didn’t feel the same then… 😦 I haven’t read that many German novels of the last decade, but one memorable one was Jenny Erpenbeck’s Gehen Ging Gegangen.
No worries. 🙂 I only started Heimsuchung but had to stop after five pages. I tried three times. Every time the same.
Shame – but as you say, we can’t all like the same things and it would be a dull world if we did!
I laughed a bit when I read your continued on in the book because you paid nine Euros for it. The relationships between mother and daughters seem interesting. She is a new to me author.
Plus P&P, don’t forget! It’s mostly mothers and children in general, although there are some interesting contrasts between mothers of daughters (Leonie) and mothers of sons (Judith).
Bravo for persevering to get your money’s worth! I’m currently wading through a 600 page monster and every time I pick it up I am whisked back to the days of homework. I am reluctant to give up though. And it did only cost 2 quid…. #tightwad
I have too much unpleasantness going on in my life at the mo’, I’ve decided, to spend time on books which feel like punishment, but I did keep hoping the pace would pick up and then it finally did. The writing is not bad, just a bit too… much of it.
Your honesty has really cheered me up, partiucalrly the comment about bloody-mindedness! (I can sympathise)
Well, I spend a fortune on books which can’t be found here in the libraries or bookshops, so I want to make sure it’s worth it…