Captivating Criminality Conference 2017

Thanks to fellow blogger and online friend Elena (whom some of you may know as @ms_adler on Twitter), I heard about the Captivating Criminality Network at Bath Spa University (in collaboration with Gdansk University in Poland. When I heard about the 2017 conference taking place on 29th June to 1st July, I was determined to attend for at least half a day. So I drove to the chi-chi Wiltshire village of Corsham on Saturday 1st July and entered the dreamy grounds of Corsham Court, where the conference was taking place. At first, I was expecting Darcy to emerge from the local pond…

Then I was intrigued by the plaintive calls from the true masters of the gardens…

But once I found my way inside The Barn, I attended some fantastic talks. I won’t give an in-depth account, but it is so refreshing to see academia engaging seriously (but not pretentiously) with crime fiction from so many different countries. These were scholars (and audiences) who really enjoyed their reading and analysis, and were experimenting with new ideas and interpretations.

You can find the full programme of the conference here.

The first panel I attended was on Newer Developments in Hard-Boiled Fiction. Arco van Ieperen from the University of Elblag in Poland compared Robert Parker’s Spenser and Harlan Coben’s Myron Bolitar, and how both of these authors changed and adapted the Chandleresque hard-boiled detective series. Both of them, for instance, evolve violent sidekicks who leave the hero free to have emotions and face ethical dilemmas. Both Spenser and Bolitar are much more respectful of women and have a grudging acceptance of political correctness. Ilse Schrynemakers from City University of New York gave a fascinating paper demonstrating how Ross Macdonald’s dysfunctional families mirrored the fears of a world living in the shadow of nuclear war. She argued convincingly how the obsessive insistence on ‘truth’ and ‘confession’ in the McCarthy era is reflected in Macdonald’s novels, albeit with a darker current. Uncovering the truth and getting the criminal to confess does not lead to remorse or redemption, but is indeed a journey from darkness to darkness.

The second panel was on one of my favourite topics: crime fiction in different geographical locations. We took a trip through Ireland, France, China and Mexico.  Jennifer Schnabel from Ohio State University talked about undercover cops in Tana French’s novels, while Eoin McCarney from Dublin City University made a very powerful comparison between Ireland and Mexico, between bog bodies and bodies dumped in the desert. Both bogs and deserts exist outside the law, outside space and time almost. Finally, Annemarie Lopez from Macquarie University in Australia used psychogeography and Jules Dassin’s Naked City to discuss urban noir. She mentioned two of my favourite authors and the rapidly changing cities they depict: Jean-Claude Izzo and Marseille,  Qiu Xiaolong and Shanghai.

The last talk I was able to attend was Professor Mary Evans from LSE (whose work on gender had been required reading on my anthropology course many years ago). In calm, measured tones, she talked about our eternal fear of loners, of people who seem to be content to be alone, and those who are desperate to belong, to fit in. She based her examples on the Stockholm trilogy by Jens Lapidus, so I found myself adding yet again to my TBR list. Being alone is an essential feature of both criminals and the detectives chasing them, yet there is a crucial difference between being alone and loneliness.

I was reminded once more how fun it is to debate ideas, methodologies and interpretations, and how much I miss these kinds of passionate academic discussions which probably sound over-specialised to others (although crime fiction festivals are a good substitute). I came away brimming with new names, new recommended titles and, above all, new ways of thinking about things. Learning as long as you live, being open to questions, trying out new things: isn’t that what life is all about?

Goodbye, Corsham Court, hope to see you again next year!


17 thoughts on “Captivating Criminality Conference 2017”

  1. Sounds fascinating! And what gorgeous surroundings. One of my new years resolutions – which I’ve actually managed to keep – was to go to more talks on literature/arts generally. I miss academia but I don’t want to return to it, so your last paragraph resonated strongly with me & I totally agree with you 🙂

    1. It’s sometimes a bit of a wrench to go and attend such events, and I feared I might not be academic enough anymore etc., but it’s a great way to get those little grey cells going again. I know university life has got its shortcomings and challengens, but now that I’ve worked in both academia and the business world, I realise all too clearly which one I was cut out for…

    1. Are you in Bath? I love that town and plan to go and visit it in a more leisurely fashion at some point. I hear it has great bookshops too…

  2. What a great way to spend a Saturday – it sounds truly fascinating! I’m especially interested in the analysis of Ross Macdonald’s novels – a journey from darkness to darkness indeed.

    1. It was a great opportunity, so grateful to them for allowing me to attend for just one day. I’d always admired Ross Macdonald’s dark world, but this really helped me to see them in their historical and social context.

  3. Oh, it sounds wonderful, Marina Sofia! All sorts of terrific ideas and conversations. And what lovely surroundings, too! I’m so glad you got the chance to enjoy it.

  4. That does sound like a wonderful day, Marina, the setting and the talks. The talk on Ross Macdonald’s dysfunctional families must have been very interesting.

  5. I’m so glad you had a great time, Marina. And it was AMAZING to finally meet you. Thank you for supporting crime fiction in academia, and for being so understanding of everything.

    1. Thank you so much for inviting me! It was great to meet you too – isn’t it funny how you feel you know people so well from their blogs etc., so you can skip all the small talk and go straight to important discussions?

  6. Reblogged this on Books and Reviews and commented:
    This year I helped organise the Captivating Criminality 4 conference at Bath Spa University (even though my tasks were little!) and I had the honour of inviting fellow blogger and reader MarinaSofia over. These are her thoughts about it:

Do share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.